近日，一则关于‘小学生站着早读被质疑没苦硬吃’的视频在网络上引发热议。画面中，一群小学生在清晨整齐站立，高声朗读课文。部分网友认为这种做法过于严苛，属于‘无谓吃苦’，不利于孩子身心健康；也有家长和教育工作者表示，站姿朗读有助于集中注意力、培养纪律意识，是传统晨读的有效形式。实际上，站着早读在中国许多学校已有多年传统，其初衷是通过身体姿态调动学习状态，避免学生因久坐或趴桌而精神涣散。教育专家指出，关键不在于是否站着，而在于教学方式是否科学、适度。若强制长时间站立、忽视个体差异，则可能适得其反；但若作为短时、有节奏的学习环节，并辅以适当引导，反而能提升学习效率。教育的本质是育人而非‘吃苦’，任何教学手段都应以学生身心发展为本。面对争议，学校不妨倾听多方声音，在传承优良传统的同时，融入现代教育理念，让早读真正成为激发兴趣、涵养习惯的积极环节，而非形式主义的‘表演’。
Recently, a video showing elementary school students standing while doing morning reading has sparked heated debate online. In the footage, a group of young students stand upright at dawn, reciting texts aloud in unison. Some netizens criticized the practice as unnecessarily harsh—imposing hardship without purpose—and potentially harmful to children’s physical and mental well-being. Others, including parents and educators, defended it, arguing that standing during recitation helps improve focus and instill discipline, making it an effective traditional approach to morning study.In fact, standing morning readings have long been a common practice in many Chinese schools. The original intent was to use posture to energize students and prevent drowsiness or distraction caused by slouching or sitting for too long. Education experts emphasize that the key issue isn’t whether students stand or sit, but whether the teaching method is scientifically sound and age-appropriate. Forcing prolonged standing without considering individual needs could backfire; however, when used briefly and rhythmically—with proper guidance—it may actually enhance learning efficiency.At its core, education should nurture growth, not enforce suffering. All teaching methods must prioritize students’ holistic development. In light of this controversy, schools are encouraged to listen to diverse perspectives, uphold beneficial traditions while integrating modern pedagogical principles, and ensure morning reading becomes a meaningful routine that fosters interest and good habits—not a performative ritual.
原创文章，作者：admin，如若转载，请注明出处：https://ktez.cn/5462.html